I don't know how but I landed on this wikipedia page today about an American rap singer called Snoop Dogg. I remembered having had some discussion about this 'artist' and his history with Khatri bhai a few days back so I got reminded of him instantly. I really admired the way the singer had mispronounced his name as 'Dogg' instead of 'Dog' because lets face it, proper pronunciation is overrated and hollow personalities lacking ioatas of characters all around the world find it difficult to express their empty and worthless ideas without the constant gnawing fear of getting exposed as shallow without riding on the crutches of a mauled and bleeding language (...not a generalization). I came to know that this guy had been charged with many crimes including murder and I really felt bad for all that he had gone through. I felt so sympathetic at one point of time, that I almost forgave him for all the shootings and muggings and killings that he might have done and that I was almost ready to forget about all those years this social evil spent driving his limo and living in his palatial home when he should have been rotting in a maximum security prison in some corner of the US and I almost was ready to turn a blind eye towards his blatant lack of musical talent because I know that in a world pestered with singers of the caliber of Paris Hilton and Himesh Reshammiya, there is only so far I can go pointing fingers at individuals before realizing that its more a trait of the society in general than segregated ineptitude.
Nevertheless, that's not even the point. My point is this: Rap is not music. Period. Wherever I go, I see people wearing extreme t-shirts, the size of their father's, tilted caps, shorts precariously hanging from points way below where they were meant to be, speaking god knows what language, their hands constantly moving in gestures which ought to ooze the word COOL but only managing to reinforce what I already know about them: STUPID. These are specifically the kind of people who listen to RAP sung by people with names like Snoop Dogg. It doesn't take Einstein then to figure out the minimum intellectual requirements required to realize the overwhelming stupidity of such kind of music. Even when Baba Sehgal during the 90s was pouring hot metal into the unsuspecting ears of Indian public in the form of the crime against humanity that were his voice and talent, I, probably a 15 year old, could tell that this could not be music. I am inclined to say that that probably was the golden age of RAP (and Eminem) and it has only gone down since then (if it was possible).
There are atleast two requirements for a good song:
1. Good music
2. Good vocals
In the absence of one, the other should more than make up for it. Like instrumental music (especially classical) or Rock. Nevertheless, the problem with RAP is that it does not have any good vocals on one hand and on the other, their proponents are just not talented enough to produce good music even. They try to make up for this lack of talent and quality in the form of raunchiness of the video and a general potrayal of hipness and coolness. Open minded people would like to give RAP the benefit of doubt but since I am not one I would just say that its crap and anyone who likes it enough to follow it closely should evaluate his life right now. Its the sound monkeys make while fighting for the last crumb of bread. Its the sound you hear when someone scratches his nails on the blackboard or screeches a rusted iron piece on a concrete floor. Things like RAP, gothism, drug culture etc. should have been boycotted long before and the only reason they survive is because of the need of some sections of the society to potray themselves as depressed and rebellious while they forget that life is a struggle for most but while most people have chosen to put up a brave face, they have chosen to take recourse to aesthetics by labeling themselves as oppressed and sidelined.
Nevertheless, that's not even the point. My point is this: Rap is not music. Period. Wherever I go, I see people wearing extreme t-shirts, the size of their father's, tilted caps, shorts precariously hanging from points way below where they were meant to be, speaking god knows what language, their hands constantly moving in gestures which ought to ooze the word COOL but only managing to reinforce what I already know about them: STUPID. These are specifically the kind of people who listen to RAP sung by people with names like Snoop Dogg. It doesn't take Einstein then to figure out the minimum intellectual requirements required to realize the overwhelming stupidity of such kind of music. Even when Baba Sehgal during the 90s was pouring hot metal into the unsuspecting ears of Indian public in the form of the crime against humanity that were his voice and talent, I, probably a 15 year old, could tell that this could not be music. I am inclined to say that that probably was the golden age of RAP (and Eminem) and it has only gone down since then (if it was possible).
There are atleast two requirements for a good song:
1. Good music
2. Good vocals
In the absence of one, the other should more than make up for it. Like instrumental music (especially classical) or Rock. Nevertheless, the problem with RAP is that it does not have any good vocals on one hand and on the other, their proponents are just not talented enough to produce good music even. They try to make up for this lack of talent and quality in the form of raunchiness of the video and a general potrayal of hipness and coolness. Open minded people would like to give RAP the benefit of doubt but since I am not one I would just say that its crap and anyone who likes it enough to follow it closely should evaluate his life right now. Its the sound monkeys make while fighting for the last crumb of bread. Its the sound you hear when someone scratches his nails on the blackboard or screeches a rusted iron piece on a concrete floor. Things like RAP, gothism, drug culture etc. should have been boycotted long before and the only reason they survive is because of the need of some sections of the society to potray themselves as depressed and rebellious while they forget that life is a struggle for most but while most people have chosen to put up a brave face, they have chosen to take recourse to aesthetics by labeling themselves as oppressed and sidelined.
8 comments:
bhaiya kya baat kar rahe ho.. Himes kya gaata hai, mazaa aa jaata hai.. Himes ko tum snoopy kutton se compare kar rahe ho! Bahut hi fighter aadmi hai Himes, gala nahi diya bhagwaan ne to naak se gaa deta hai bechara. Himes jindabad.
Well I disagree with you when you say there are 2 requirements of a good song. In my view a good song has 4 requirements:
1.Lyrics
2.Melody
3.Rhythm
4.Vocals
But yes in absence of one, others must compensate.
and for Rap lovers which you so criticize would probably find a Hindustani Classical recital to be boring/dull/staid.
The music that you appreciate I think largely comes from the culture you inherit. And obviously that is something we cant criticize. Although you could have a opinion about.
And yeah Himesh rocks !!
Hello my little Nazi!
(Now do not say that it doesn't even makes any sense)
@Phantom: haan... Himesh jaise log na hon to main to jobless hi ho jaaoonga na :)
@Anurup: Well, I would not want to add lyrics to the requirements for a good song but they surely do beautiful tinges. Nevertheless, I feel that, really good music should not depend too heavily on lyrics since it introduces a cultural barrier which is inherently contradictory to its universal appeal. As for your other point, it makes me think. Should I not criticize a particular culture on grounds of sensitivity ? Is there something absolutely contemptible ? Which again takes us to the age old question of good and bad and their fundamental definitions. Pretty heavy, eh?
@Kilas: It makes perfect sense :). Because there is still some time when I can be termed a full blown Nazi. Till then, 'little Nazi' works just fine :)...
"...they have chosen to take recourse to aesthetics by labeling themselves as oppressed and sidelined."
I would've agreed with you if you had used the above line in the context of artists whose work compels empathy in an observer, not for rappers. While both sets of people can claim similar surroundings as the inspiration for their works, there is beauty in one and ugliness in the other. It's not the symphony/cacophony alone that forces this division, it's their obvious motivations.
hilton is a singer????!!!!!
Railgaadi .......Railgaadi...
remember ??? the first rap of Indian Cinema..Dude !!! people went mad over this new genre of music..although it was not ingeminated for a long time..
but ya...that epoch has now taken over by dandy BigB singing with the naked ladies ( Bunty or Babli...)....
@Kowsik: I think you have put it very clearly. I should write about EMO then :)
@Doodler: ha! surprised ? This world is more screwed up than we imagine :)
@Devendra: I haven't seen it yet. Tried watching it once but fell asleep after about 3 seconds of the start :)
Post a Comment